Monday, 24 March 2014

University Challenge 2013-14: Semi-Final 1: Trinity vs Manchester

So, we've arrived at the semi-finals of what has been a good series of UC. The winners of tonight's match would become the first time to reach the final. Unlike last year, the draw for the semis has not put the two unbeaten teams together to avoid a rematch. I'll let you decide for yourself whether that's for the best or not.

Trinity College Cambridge got here the direct way, defeating Christ Church Oxford, Peterhouse Cambridge, Manchester (their opponents tonight) and SOAS (also in the semis). The favourites for tonight's match were the same four as before:
Matthew Ridley, from Northumberland, studying Economics
Filip Drnovšek Zorko, from Slovenia, studying Natural Sciences
Captain: Ralph Morley, from Ashford in Kent, studying Classics
Richard Freeland, from Cowbridge in Glamorgan, studying Maths

Reigning champions Manchester got here by beating Brasenose College Oxford, Queens' College Cambridge, Cardiff and our old friends Southampton, but they also lost to Trinity between the Queens' and Cardiff matches. They were also the same foursome as their previous outings:
Edward Woudhuysen, from London, studying History
Joe Day, from Bideford in Devon, studying Physics with Astrophysics
Captain: Elizabeth Mitchell, from Birmingham, studying PPE
Jonathan Collings, from Manchester, studying Geography

Apart from that previous victory for Trinity over Manchester, very little between these two good teams on paper. It could've gone either way.

It was Trinity who got off the mark first, with Matthew Ridley getting the first starter; but then JOW and LAM contributor Filip 'opaltiger' Drnovšek Zorko slipped up, and allowed Manchester to get off the mark as well. The Mancunians maintained an early advantage on the buzzer, and after the first picture round, on Latin excerpts from poems, they led by 55-20.

Back hit Trinity though, with two correct starters in a row and a good handful of bonuses allowing them to catch up and draw level. But then a second slip-up allowed Manchester to take back the lead. Our man Filip was a little lucky on the next starter, pausing for a moment before answering and getting told off for doing so. The bonuses did allow them to reclaim the lead, but not for long, as Manchester swiftly reclaimed it, with Jonathan Collings once again giving a good buzzer performance.

Mr Collings also took the music starter, and the bonuses, on performers who have received the Royal Philharmonic Society's gold medal for Outstanding Musicianship, gave his side a lead of 115-75. Two more starters fell Mr Collings' way, and the bonuses that went with them saw Manchester's lead rise two 80 points. Trinity looked in trouble, but Ralph Morley promptly shot in on the next starter, and they were back in the game.

Neither side took the picture starter, but Trinity took the next starter to take the picture bonuses, on portraits of Scottish writers; they took all the bonuses, closing the gap to 155-120. A slip-up from Joe Day handed another starter, but no bonuses followed this time. Mr Day promptly made up for his error, and Manchester's lead went up again.

But Trinity had now got into gear, and in the closing minutes of the match, began to build up a head of steam. The starters began falling for them, and they maintained their good bonus showing from throughout the night. They had soon drawn level, and then our man Filip took them into the lead.

All they had to do now was not make any more mistakes on the buzzer, and they had likely done enough. They didn't, and soon had built up a substantial lead with surely not much time left. A chance did come for Manchester to get back in, but they couldn't take it. At the gong, Trinity had won the match 260-175.

That was exhausting! Very well done to Filip and co for a great recovery, and a well deserved win and place in the final; best of luck to yous for then! But very well done Manchester too; it may not be a third title in a row, but you reached the semis again, and that in itself in a great achievement. Well done indeed!

On the buzzers, Messrs Morley and Freeland got four starters each for Trinity, while Jonathan Collings was once again the best buzzer for Manchester with six; he finishes the series his side's best buzzer by miles with thirty-six(!), a total that may be enough to make him the best buzzer of the series. On the bonuses, Trinity converted a brilliant 28 out of 37 (with two penalties), while Manchester managed an also very good 18 out of 27 (with one penalty). Superb work there; shame this wasn't the final really.

So, I can only presume it's Somerville vs SOAS next week; whoever wins that will deserve to join Trinity in the final. Best of luck both teams!

6 comments:

  1. I just wanted to say: Ralph Morley, if you're listening... you devious little so-and-so!

    Seriously, I'm very pleased to see Trinity win this. However nice the new quarter-finals system is for giving us more chance to see some great matches, particularly this season; it threw up the sad anomaly last season of UCL beating Manchester only to lose to them in the final, which was a bit of a shame; although, to be fair to Manchester, the final is where it counts the most! They were worthy winners, really.

    It's nice to see Manchester's chance to win three times in a row gone, in a way, too. The same University winning over and over wouldn't be good for the show I think, so nice to see a change. Then again, this year's Manchester team was probably better than last year's so they can feel hard done by.

    Which brings me to Ralph Morley. I've mentioned before that we met, at the 2013 varsity quiz, and on the way back from our defeats at the hands of teams including the likes of Chris Beer and Hasneen Karbalai (and Christ Church's Ewan MacAulay was there too, and Tom Finch who featured in St. John's College Oxford team this season... quizzing is a small world (oh and finally 2008 winner Alex Bubb)) ... anyway, where was I? Oh yes, well Ralph and I were walking back home and cheekily I asked him who was going to win this season of Uni Challenge. He kept mum, but I did ask if it was at least "not Manchester?" A sad expression passed over his face, and so I've spent the last ten months or so thinking sure that it was going to be a Manchester hat-trick. And, with Trinity down 75-155, it seemed nailed on for the Manchester victory that I "knew" was coming... then I was very pleasantly surprised to see Trinity recover, catch up, overtake and pull away in the dying minutes!!

    No idea who will win this series now... but Ralph, if you're reading this, thanks for not letting on after all!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Unbelievably relieved/happy after this. Watching it just now I was pretty sure they'd blown it.

    It's no secret that I'm a bit of an 'anyone-but-Manchester' guy, but as a Trinitarian I had much more of a direct interest. I also cannot stand teams which are so overwhelmingly carried by 'the one old dude on the end' (there's no doubt that Collings is a pretty excellent quizzer, though). (Out of interest, does anyone know who Manchester's second best buzzer of the series was?) Over the series I've been far more impressed by Trinity than Manchester so I'm fairly confident the best team won on the night.

    Oh, and this game threw up a classic Paxo science bias with the guess of '...livnorium? ...livornium?' being accepted for Livermorium. Would like to know if there was a pause in filming while they reviewed it - I'd've certainly been inclined to challenge.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Tell me about it. I was pretty certain we'd blown it too.

      I'm pretty sure Day is second for Manchester.

      I don't think there was a pause for that, but there WAS one for nodes of Ranvier and in hindsight they really should have let us have that if Manchester got their element.

      Delete
    2. Yeah agreed. I noticed a bit of a 'cut' on the Ranvier one so did wonder. Just glad it didn't even come close to making the difference! (And well done :D)

      Delete
    3. I don't have statistics for the whole series, so I don't know who Manchester's second best buzzer of the series was. However, I do know that Elizabeth Mitchell was the best buzzer for Manchester in their first-round match

      http://jacksonlinewritings.blogspot.co.uk/2013/08/university-challenge-2013-14-round-1_26.html

      and that Joe Day was the best buzzer for Manchester in their quarter-final against Trinity

      http://jacksonlinewritings.blogspot.co.uk/2014/01/university-challenge-2013-14.html

      and so I think that Michael is allowing his self-confessed 'anyone but Manchester' attitude to cloud his thinking a little in saying that "I also cannot stand teams which are so overwhelmingly carried by 'the one old dude on the end'".

      And yes, I must confess that I'm a Mancunian, so I'm probably a bit biased too, but not so much that I won't admit that Trinity deserved their victory.

      Delete
    4. Haha, well I was mainly going from the write-up's "he finishes the series his side's best buzzer by miles". I suspect if I'm mistaken it's not so much down to a Manchester bias, but just an old-people-on-UC bias - I'm similarly hopeful that SOAS don't make it through.

      Delete